Official website for games™ - The multi award-winning MULTIFORMAT games magazine

The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword review

Reviews
11 Nov 2011

After twenty-five years and sixteen games, Nintendo celebrates Link’s birthday with a breathtaking voyage through Hyrule with The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword. It’s the Zelda the Wii was made for.

The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword reviewOh, Nintendo. Trust the company that brought us the Virtual Boy, FLUDD the water-shooting backpack and, just recently, the bolt-on analogue stick, to leave it six whole years before releasing a game that embraces the Wii’s unique features on every conceivable level, and in doing so makes the console downright essential for any and all core gamers in one fell swoop of a giant crimson wing.

Imagine your favourite bit of a Zelda game. Ocarina Of Time’s vast, explorable landscape, perhaps? What about Wind Waker’s massive ocean of blue to pioneer? Or perhaps you were all about Twilight Princess’s tricksy sword moves and bug hunting? All those staples are present and correct, and in spades too; clearly in a concerted effort to pull together myriad factors of Zelda lore for this 25th anniversary celebration. But the most important and outstanding truth about Skyward Sword is that it does so much more besides. And that so much more is original, dynamic and, most thrillingly, a true progression for the series, even while this instalment delights in steeping itself so much in its past glories.

As ever, Link begins the game awaking from a moody teenage slumber, but this time he’s not been dreaming about Triforces or scary men from the desert. No, this time it’s a titanic, slavering beast trying to gnaw his face off, snapping and snarling in a way that you just dread, inevitably, facing in boss form later. It’s a stark contrast to his comfy home life. A bird-riding knight-in-training in a floating town known as Skyloft, it’s not long before Link’s plunged into a predictable, tacky and generally unfunny opening hour or so of sub-Saved By The Bell high school drama. The big bully, the leering sidekicks, a sabotaged race and a desperation for all concerned to win the affections of a certain blonde-haired, pale-skinned headmaster’s daughter serve as a plodding introductory act, but at the very least set up the game’s impressionistic visuals and joyful, fully orchestral soundtrack to be something far more upbeat than Twilight Princess’s attempts to be dark. And besides, all the handholding and humorous asides are a good enough way to become accustomed to the single most important new feature in Skyward Sword – the extremely novel control system.

The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword reviewMake no mistake: Skyward Sword’s interaction is light years away from Twilight Princess’s mumbled excuse for motion control. From basic downward, sideways and diagonal slashes to thrusts and even a shield block and parry function by brandishing the Nunchuk, the sword control is as close to one-to-one communication between Wii Remote and Link’s right hand as could be hoped for. Utilising everything learned from the likes of Wii Sports Resort and Wii Play Motion, Nintendo has finally become perfectly at home with the nuances of its controller. Combat is almost entirely focused on correct and skilful wielding of the sword, with even the simplest enemies anticipating and blocking attacks, lending every encounter a swashbuckling quality previously unseen in the comparatively by rote run-and-slash fighting of previous Zelda titles.

Further, Nintendo being Nintendo, it’s not long before this emphasis on wielding the Remote begins to blossom into wider, ever more intriguing ways to interact with the game on numerous levels.

From raising the sword in the air, He-Man-style, to power the weapon up for a ‘Skyward Strike’ projectile attack, to confounding a giant eyeball guarding a door by spinning the sword in 360-degree rotations, to solving puzzles by slashing in sequences or inserting the sword into puzzle blocks, the wider game is keenly designed around the blade, making it a key tool in far more situations than just combat.

The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword reviewThe motion control focus doesn’t stop there either, of course, with almost every one of Link’s new toys somehow driven by hand movements. Simple, analogue aiming with the slingshot moves swiftly to swinging a whip, or even piloting a tiny beetle through the skies, its pincers able to collect items or carry and drop bombs with a superb top-down camera mode, every new collectable creating another new twist for the Wii Remote’s possibilities. At the same time, many of the items and weapons are now upgradeable at Skyloft’s marketplace, or by meeting certain characters in the narrative. This adds a new meaning to inventory completion, hoarding the game’s many collectable minerals, feathers and even bugs in order to keep building on what you’ve already got. The extended adaptation of items also means that they continue to be useful throughout the game; a far cry from the one-hit wonders many pick-ups have been in the past, used extensively in one dungeon or one boss and never seen again.

This holistic approach covers the entirety of Skyward Sword, each element carefully intertwined with the rest, more care than ever before having been taken to ensure each separate gameplay device links intelligently with every other. It’s exactly in line with Nintendo’s promises to structure the game in new and attention-grabbing ways. It means that, while Skyward Sword still unfurls its story and possibilities in as linear a manner as the series ever has, a sense of exploration and scale has still managed to return to the series that, arguably – due to developmental approach or the simple limitations of 3D technology – hasn’t been seen since the freedoms offered by the very first adventure back in 1986.

The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword reviewThe way this has been achieved is with a firm sense of pacing. Ocarina Of Time’s Hyrule Field was packed with elements, but regrettably small, while Twilight Princess or Wind Waker’s aquatic versions contained many of the same destinations, but with a great amount of empty space in between. Skyward Sword brilliantly solves this problem of scale versus exploration by splitting the open world and the focused, adventure sections neatly in two. The sky – Link’s childhood home and location of the Skyloft town – now fulfils the role of the large, explorable area, Link’s enormous red bird rideable around its entirety with deft flicks of the Remote causing his mount to flap, dive and swoop. At the touch of a button, however, Link can leap from the bird, freefalling through the air. From here, he can drop into portals that lead to specific areas of ‘the surface’ below, exploring several key (and instantly familiar) sectors of the apparently abandoned and wild world below Skyloft. It’s an extremely clever approach to creating gameplay value and scope in each area, as there’s far more going on in each region than simply following, as so many times before, a set path towards the next dungeon.

While it’s true that these wider slices of environmental exploration revolve essentially around finding and collecting things, it’s a formula that’s twisted up so often that the repetition is hidden behind a carefully calculated smokescreen of fun. Whether scouring a forest for lost members of the excellent Totoro-like Kyui Tribe, or placing beacons on the area map to uncover ancient pathways long-buried under a desert, these fetch quests often cover areas of the world easily as large as Ocarina’s entire Hyrule Field. They’re also made decidedly less linear than they could have been by way of the sword’s dousing ability which, in a first-person perspective, turns the weapon into a flashing, pulsating beacon to point Link in the direction of the next pick-up.

The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword reviewGetting around these areas largely on foot, meanwhile, is an experience that borrows more than a little from Assassin’s Creed, immediately making the traditionally ponderous Link one of gaming’s more energetic heroes. He’s been beefed up to a satisfying level of athletic prowess, running up low walls to grab platforms and overhangs, and dashing at speed until his new stamina bar runs down. The stamina bar governs almost every facet of Link’s moves, in fact, with ill-planned vine-climbing sessions ending in disaster should he run out of the energy to keep climbing, or wading through quicksand to reach islands ending abruptly as he sinks to his death. Several memorable situations even see Link staggering up sharp slopes, dodging boulders hurled from enemies above as he struggles to reach safe outcrops before it’s too late.

Swordfighting, too, is affected by the stamina bar, particularly in duelling boss encounters in which feinting and resisting the temptation to telegraph moves is key to landing crucial hits. It’s just another layer of subtlety which makes the swordplay feel almost as immediate, and filled with as much unlimited potential, as the first time you laid hands on an analogue-controlled Mario in the plumber’s first N64 outing.

The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword reviewBut after all this, there are still dungeons to consider, and they’re up there with the best the series has offered. Starting intimate but tricky, the first few dispense with the time-honoured separate, colour-coded floor maps, bringing the detail of the overworld map into plans far more useful for navigation beyond guesswork. But you’ll need the extra help, Link’s increased nimbleness and more nuanced toolset forcing more balls than ever before to be juggled simultaneously to achieve results. The game’s save system has finally been evolved to match the challenge, too, with bird-shaped stone statues now serving as manual save points, appearing mid-dungeon (sometimes in almost every room) and offering the ability, as well as saving, to leave the dungeon mid-puzzle or even teleport back to Skyloft to stock up on supplies, fix a shield or otherwise upgrade your inventory.

Skyward Sword takes Zelda in a direction in which the challenge is no longer in limiting the player’s abilities, but in choosing which of a great many skills is fit for task. A fully-functional right arm would be a powerful tool to apply to any adventure game, but Nintendo takes these possibilities and makes them truly explode, crafting a world that almost perfectly melds a quarter of a century of gaming tradition with technology that still feels absolutely current.

Zelda: Skyward Sword may be the swansong for the Wii, and may be overshadowed by a mere tech demo that showed Link in unrivalled detail on Nintendo’s next-generation offering. But it’s the game the Wii was born to run, and a Zelda game that showcases the kind of talent and ingenuity many seem recently to have entirely forgotten that Nintendo is really all about. Spellbinding, dramatic and absolutely epic in both the world it paints and the story it tells, Zelda: Skyward Sword is a hugely important event for the Wii, for Nintendo, and for anyone with even a passing love for the venerable series it celebrates. But overall, it’s an utterly essential videogame; a flash of fantastical brilliance in an increasingly commercial field of production line entertainment. Buffed and polished to a perfect point, Zelda: Skyward Sword is one in the eye for the naysayers, and a spectacular return to form for its developer; a solemn reminder that, when it comes to crafting worlds, nobody does it quite like Nintendo.
VERDICT 9 /10
Playing the Wii out in style
Follow our Twitter for all the latest videogames news, reviews, previews, interviews and features, while our Facebook fan page is the best place to communicate with other fans of games™ magazine.
  • bluesplus1

    So if it’s been buffed up “to a perfect point,” in what way is it a 9 and not a 10?
    Elaborate.

  • monkey

    obviously the reviewer doesnt know how to make the score

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AHGJ3LYTX64ZYGCOCJSRC4QAVE raheem l

    guessing since its not in hd… 

  • Super

    Editor does score reviewer does review :P

  • Christopher Cates

    So basically the writer does the review… the Editor receives money from publisher. 
    If money is received: 10
    If no money received: Highest is a 9

    Makes sense.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=698016236 Kevin Douglas Femmel

    Who cares about a score? Its good. Should anything really get perfect scores? Not really. Are we sometimes seduce into giving perfect scores by awesome software that has us fall head over heels for it at the moment? Yes. It’s good, but a 9 isn’t bad. I hate it when stuff gets perfect scores. There’s no point to that, of course there will be things to tack off points.

  • Scott

    Y U NO 10

  • Zeldawg

    BOOM.

  • YourTurnBEN

    Review or preview?

  • zeldadude

    bastards… give it a ten!. the text in this review does not equal a 9

  • Nilaul

    Metacritic ignored this review… something about bashing that its not on a HD console.

  • Nilaul

    Metacritic ignored this review, something about the reviewer stating that it should had been on a HD console, didnt quite make the cut.

  • giggsy13

    this mag gave mario galaxy 2 a 10 and this review reads like it is one of the best and most important games in living memory. why not a 10!!!!??? The reason i want a 10 is that if this ends up GOTY then the COD generation just MIGHT sit up and notice there is more to gaming then collecting guns and calling in airstrikes…………

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mike-Arnold/807895458 Mike Arnold

    how can you read this and not vomit

  • Trinidad

    ya the content and the way the editor wrote this article in no way equals a 9. It would be at least a 9.5 just from a quick read and overtone. The only negative thing I found was the first hour of the game….. gahhh this pisses me off

  • VDZ

    The problem isn’t that he rated it a 9, the problem is that he rated it a 9 without having a single point of criticism towards the game. He even calls it “buffed and polished to a perfect point”. A review singing praise without writing about a single weak point should conclude with ’10/10′, not ’9/10′. 9/10 would indicate that although it’s an amazing game, it still has some flaws. Not giving it a 10/10 yet not mentioning any flaws in his review means either the review sucks or the score is wrong.

  • gosc

    “A bird-riding knight-in-training in a floating town known as Skyloft, it’s not long before Link’s plunged into a predictable, tacky and generally unfunny opening hour or so of sub-Saved By The Bell high school drama. The big bully, the leering sidekicks, a sabotaged race and a desperation for all concerned to win the affections of a certain blonde-haired, pale-skinned headmaster’s daughter serve as a plodding introductory act, but at the very least set up the game’s impressionistic visuals and joyful, fully orchestral soundtrack to be something far more upbeat than Twilight Princess’s attempts to be dark.”

  • http://www.sonicyouth.com/dotsonics/kim/ Kim Gordon

    Uh, they *did* elaborate.  Re-read the third paragraph.

  • http://www.sonicyouth.com/dotsonics/kim/ Kim Gordon

    Re-read the third paragraph.

  • http://www.sonicyouth.com/dotsonics/kim/ Kim Gordon

    10 would mean that the game is perfect.  Re-read the third paragraph.  There is a criticism, so it would make no sense to give the game a perfect score.

  • Bronson

    Could you just match the score with the review you did here? It’s like I’m reading something that remarks the quality of a legendary title, but the score put it at the level of other “common and good games”.

    Shame on you and this crappy wall text you wrote.

  • Bronson

    Could you just match the score with the review you did here? It’s like I’m reading something that remarks the quality of a legendary title, but the score put it at the level of other “common and good games”.

    Shame on you and this crappy wall text you wrote.

  • Guest

    Right. Any game that doesn’t start guns blazing should warrant a negative point. Most RPGs = shit.

  • me!

    bastards! how you can give to this game a 9 , is inconceivable.XD…nahhh just kidding !!!…seriously, is true, the scores and notes does not matter.. the final user is   who decided the quality of the game..but no one will deny that we all want to see in all reviews are 10 everywhere…reviewers re-evaluate this game..come on, all makes mistakes, but  ”give back to Caesar what is Caesar’s, and to God what is God’s”.

  • Ads64

    ?????

  • Laurent

    Well the game is marvellous, magical and perfect but its 9/10 o_O

  • Rational

    For christ’s sake, you people are absurdly whiny. The reviewer adores the game and says that most of it is awesome, but the first hour or so is pretty bad. Because of the first hour, the reviewer didn’t think the game deserved a perfect score, which is reasonable. GamesTM only gives whole number scores, so they gave it a 9.

    I imagine most of you as the sort of kids who pout when they only get fun-sized candy bars instead of full-sized ones when they go out trick-or-treatiing with their parents.

  • Pingback: The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword review | Videogames … | industry, blog, iphone, app, creative, games, programming, project, various, criminalminds

  • Pingback: The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword – Was sagt die internationale Fachpresse? » playm.de

  • KeeperOfTheWord

    Holy shit, 80% of you commenters are genuinely mentally retarded. Please empty your dribble trays like good boys and girls and leave the commenting to those with full mental faculties.

  • Pingback: The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword reviews rounded up — Gematsu

  • Pingback: A Collection of Skyward Sword Reviews

  • Marcus Stockley

    @ NilaulStop spreading false tales you troll.What is with you people? The game doesn’t get a 10/10 and suddenly GAMEStm are Wii haters with a hard-on for HD gaming? HD makes games look crisp and brings out details but who cares; the magazine clearly doesn’t mention it!It got a stunning score worthy of any masterpiece and yet there are still whinners? Good greif, no wonder the videogame crowd is still looked down on….

  • BabyWuigi

    There was not one negative thing said about this game in the review. You make it sound perfect so should we not get to know what the game has done wrong, causing it to lose a point. 9 is a great score but your review sounds like it should be a 10!

  • Pingback: Noticias Zelda | Todas las Noticias Zelda

  • Pingback: The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword, i voti delle prime recensioni

  • Marcus Stockley

    To the person who stated, “Metacritic ignored this review… something about bashing that its not on a HD console” you are obviously a person who doesn’t look up facts. Not only is it on the site it’s not the only magazine/website to give the game a 9/10. Mature people, real mature….

  • Marcus Stockley

    To the person who stated, “Metacritic ignored this review… something about bashing that its not on a HD console” you are obviously a person who doesn’t look up facts. Not only is it on the site it’s not the only magazine/website to give the game a 9/10. Mature people, real mature….

  • Pingback: Epic. - User Reviews - www.GameInformer.com

  • http://www.gamerelatedblog.com/ StriderNo9

    Great review.

  • http://www.gamerelatedblog.com/ StriderNo9

    LOL thanks for saying it so I didn’t have to.

  • McSlenderman

    Everyone is complaining that this game didn’t get a perfect score, and their reason is because the review made it sound perfect. Who wants to make a bet that if they gave this game a perfect score and a review that didn’t make it sound perfect, these fanboys wouldn’t care? Stop being hypocrites.

  • http://www.fotografia.one.ayz.pl Freddie Heiderman

    hi!,I like your writing so much! share we communicate more about your article on AOL? I require a specialist on this area to solve my problem. Maybe that’s you! Looking forward to see you.

  • http://www.chatbook.in/blogs/entry/China-surpassed-the-U-S-PC-shipments SwertySheby
  • TheRedMage

    It’s not very good, this game. Awful control system.